Starting in 1996, the outstanding senior wrestler award has been given to the Yuma High wrestler who best shows the qualities of leadership, integrity, and skill during his career.  Chance Farrar was given the award post graduation for his contributions to the program.  There was not a senior chosen in 1995.

1994	Chance Farrar
1995	No award given
1996	Eric Guerrero
1997	Johnny Hurtado
1998	Wally Johnson
1999	Jack Smith and Roger Valdez
2000	Adrian Mendivil
2001	Pedro Sanchez, Jr.
2002	Aaron Wine
2003	Jesus Jimenez

2004	Brock Williamson
2005